Victoria Starr recently explored Sicily and the Aeolian Islands, sharing her firsthand experiences at some of the region’s most luxurious and unique properties. From hillside retreats to seaside hideaways, here’s her insider take on the best places to stay on your next Sicilian escape.
Donna Carmela – A Hilltop Gem Between Catania and Taormina
Donna Carmela is conveniently located between Catania and Taormina, offering a serene start to any Sicilian itinerary. Part of the Small Luxury Hotels (SLH) collection, the property blends natural beauty with modern comfort.
Victoria stayed in a lower category room, which she describes as small but perfectly adequate for a short stay. The hotel offers a wide range of accommodations, including modern lodges separate from the main property, providing extra privacy.
Highlights of Donna Carmela include:
- Hilltop location with sweeping views of farmlands and the sea
- Incredible on-site restaurant featuring local cuisine
- Beautiful gardens and poolside experiences
- Spa treatments available (Victoria’s husband called his massage one of the best he’s ever had)
- Easy access to Mt. Etna experiences
Victoria notes that she wished she had booked an extra night to fully enjoy the property and its offerings.
Principe di Salina – Barefoot Luxury in the Aeolian Islands
Nestled on the island of Salina, Principe di Salina is ideal for travelers seeking to go off the beaten path. Salina’s lush volcanic mountains meet the azure sea, offering an enchanting escape from Sicily’s more crowded areas.
Victoria stayed in a second-story room with a private terrace, where she spent hours soaking in the views and sea breeze. The room was small but thoughtfully designed, featuring Ortigia of Sicily bath products and a comfortable bed. Suites are also available.
Why Principe di Salina stands out:
- Hilltop location in the charming town of Malfa
- Boutique, barefoot luxury with abundant common areas
- On-site restaurant serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner on the terrace or poolside
- Proximity to beaches, hiking, wine tastings, and boat excursions (including night tours along Stromboli to watch volcanic eruptions!)
- Easy access to neighboring islands via hydrofoil
- Walking distance to excellent dining options, including a Michelin-starred restaurant
Victoria emphasizes that Salina is her favorite island in Sicily and suggests a stay of 5 days on Salina and 2–3 days on Volcano for easy access to Panarea and Stromboli. She notes that other hotels in Malfa can’t compare in grounds or service.
Le Calette – A Relaxed Yet Elegant Coastal Retreat in Cefalù
Le Calette, also part of the Small Luxury Hotels group, is located about a mile outside Cefalù. This resort-like property offers the perfect balance of remoteness and accessibility, with a quiet sea-view walk into town or a short taxi ride.
Victoria’s highlights from Le Calette:
- Upgraded to a Seaview suite with vaulted ceilings, a seating area, and a large terrace overlooking the ocean and pool
- Three dining options: a poolside restaurant, a fine dining main building option, and a casual yet elegant cliffside restaurant (her favorite)
- Summer beach club with private swimming cove
- Full-service spa with attentive staff treating guests like family
- Understated luxury vibe, ideal for travelers who have visited Positano, Capri, or Taormina but seek fewer crowds
Victoria was impressed with the food options, which she found exceptional considering the size of the town. The property is roughly an hour from Palermo.
Atlantis Bay – Secluded Luxury in Taormina
Atlantis Bay is Victoria’s pick for a luxury Taormina stay without the summer crowds. Located about a 10-minute drive from the town center, the hotel is built into a private cliffside bay, offering breathtaking views of the sea and rocky islets lined with palms and cacti.
Key features:
- Secluded, cliffside location in its own private bay
- Newly renovated rooms with large terraces overlooking the bay
- Perfect for travelers who want luxury and privacy while still accessing Taormina
- Ideal for clients seeking a more affordable alternative to the Belmond
Victoria notes that she would stay at Atlantis Bay again in a heartbeat, praising the hotel’s character, charm, and sense of exclusivity.
Sicily offers a wealth of luxurious, intimate properties for travelers seeking unforgettable stays. Whether you’re looking for a hilltop retreat, a barefoot island escape, a serene coastal resort, or a secluded cliffside haven, Victoria Starr’s insights ensure you know where to stay to make your Sicilian journey truly exceptional.